 Phở tái đạp, Nha Trang, Vietnam |
 Phở tái đạp, Phở Hà Nội (SJ) |
Mention Vietnamese food, and chances are the first thing to pop into people’s minds, is phở. Perhaps the most well-known of all Vietnamese cuisine, phở is beginning to appear more and more in mainstream American culture. I even bought a “What the Phở?” t-shirt a few years ago, which I still wear around the house.
When I was little, growing up in upstate New York in the 1980s, if my family wanted phở, my mom would have to make it—there were no phở restaurants that we knew of to go to. She would spend the whole day cooking, and the house would fill the with delicious aromas that came from the humongous pot which would feed our entire extended family for the day. After we moved to California, my mom retired her phở recipe, saying it was too easy to buy a bowl of phở from people who knew how to cook it better than she did.
Considering the abundance of phở joints around town, finding a decent bowl of phở is relatively easy to do in San Jose. It’s finding a stellar bowl that is the annoyingly difficult part (annoying because of the plethora of phở restaurants that I have to muddle through and the inevitable duds along the way). As I work along my mission, eating through countless phở bowls, the question I keep in my mind is “Where would I take Anthony Bourdain to eat phở?” I have a feeling that locating my best phở recommendation will become my own personal Moby Dick—albeit a delicious, steamy, and comfy Moby Dick. Being such, my recommendation will be a work in progress, changing as I discover better bowls along the way.
The criteria I considered in rating a good bowl of phở are:
Noodles—must not be too hard, or too mushy (yes, that’s the technical term).
Broth—flavor, flavor, flavor. A bad broth (bland or too salty) can kill a bowl of phở. Also, according to my mom, the mark of a good broth is how clear it is.
Meat—tenderness is a must. Tái should be raw when brought out, and should cook in front of you, in the broth.
Fixings (variety, freshness, quantity)—bean sprouts, lime, sliced jalapenos, rau quế (Thai basil), cilantro (ngò gai).
 Phở garnish, Nha Trang, Vietnam |
 Phở tái, Pho Y #1 (SJ) |
Disclaimer: Considering that there are a number of different types of phở (phở gà/chicken phở, phở bò viên/phở with meatballs, phở tái chín/phở with well-done meat, etc.), I stuck to good old phở tái/phở with rare meat. It’s my favorite, and it made it easier to compare apples to apples sticking to just one type of phở to review.
With that said, I have two recommendations for a good bowl of phở—one southern style, and one northern style. Coincidentally, they are less than a few minutes away from one another:
Phở Ý #1 (1660 E. Capitol Expressway, San Jose, CA, 95121 (408) 274-1769)
Hands down, the meat at Phở Y was the best I have ever had in a bowl of phở. Thinly sliced, generous portions, extremely tender. The meat alone nudged the place into the lead of the southern style phở restaurants. The noodles were also cooked to perfection, and was in just the right proportion to the broth. The fixings were average, and was the one thing the restaurant skimped on—but this can be easily remedied by asking for more. The broth was a little salty and nothing to write home about, but it was decent.
Phở Ý doesn’t mess around when it comes to phở. The restaurant doesn’t have much ambiance (think cafeteria), and they don’t serve gỏi cuốn (spring rolls), chả giò (eggrolls), or any other standard fare that is typically found at other phở places. So if you go there, you’ll be going for the phở.
Phở Ha Noi (1759 E Capitol Expy, San Jose, CA, 95121 (408) 239-0888—closed Wednesdays)
I hadn’t heard of northern style phở until this past year (although technically, all phở is northern style, since phở originated in North Viet Nam). After doing some research, Phở Ha Noi caught my eye because of the fact that it makes its own noodles daily! I had to try it. The noodles are available in regular thin size, or a thicker size. It’s really just a matter of preference, but in any case, the fresh noodles make a big difference. The noodles have more flavor and a tender, silkier, less starchy texture.
What is the difference between northern and southern style phở, you might ask? Northern phở has what I can best describe as beaten beef or tái đạp and is much simpler. Traditional northern phở is just meat, noodles, green onions, and broth—a straight up meat-and-potatoes-in-soup type dish. None of the herbs, lime, chili, bean sprouts, or other garnishes that you find in southern style. However, they will bring out a plate of greens—extremely fresh greens, which is a big plus for me—if you ask them to (and most people do, since many of us are so used to the garnishes of southern style phở).
The meat at Phở Ha Noi is very tender (probably from being beaten) and in good proportion to the broth. It comes out raw, and cooks in the broth, as a good bowl phở tái should. The broth itself is less flavorful than I’m used to, but still very tasty.
-Myvan
 Phở Bò, Golden Star (SF) |
 Pho Garden's Pho Challenge |
Mimi’s SF Recommendations:
Yummy Yummy (1015 Irving Street , San Francisco, CA 94122 (415) 566-4722)
The #1 XL bowl of phở is a steep $8 but has a rich, clear broth with a good amount of tender meats and fresh onions. The bowl stays piping hot throughout the meal and is so satisfying on those foggy SF days.
Golden Star Vietnamese Restaurant (11 Walter U Lum Place, SF, CA 94108 (415) 398-1215)
Rumor has it that at Golden Star, they’ve been boiling down the same pot of broth for years. That may not be appealing to some, but to the true phở lovers that just translates into an extra deep broth you must try when you’re in Chinatown.
Phở Garden (2109 Clement St, San Francisco, CA 94121 (415) 379-8677)
Though not my favorite phở I can’t talk about SF pho without mentioning the Phở Challenge at Phở Garden. To fulfill your Man vs. Food dreams and have your picture posted on the wall, you will need to finish eating 2 lbs of meat (tripe, tendon, tái, bò viên) and 2 lbs of noodles in one hour (you don’t need to finish the soup); if you lose, you pay the $22. The specially made ceramic bowl is massive and you may not want to eat phở for a very long time. Good luck!